Resistor Value Hack

Hand-tuned boutique resistors! Could be a whole new marketing frontier.
You can go pretty deep into resistors. Vishay has “naked foil resistors” that cost in the low $30s each a decade ago, when I used a few in a project. Caddock has something similar. The main advantages are in low self noise and low capacitance. (These were ~ 1/2 watt resistors; I think they made larger ones, that got quite a bit more expensive.)
 
You can go pretty deep into resistors. Vishay has “naked foil resistors” that cost in the low $30s each a decade ago, when I used a few in a project. Caddock has something similar. The main advantages are in low self noise and low capacitance. (These were ~ 1/2 watt resistors; I think they made larger ones, that got quite a bit more expensive.)
Geez! I thought I was fancy spending the extra $.003 for the metal film ones.
 
What resistor can possibly be so critical, in a guitar pedal context, that it can't be found, closely enough, in the widely available, el-cheapo, 1%/E96 series? 🤔
And who still uses carbon resistors? (asking for a friend who has a vintage, B&W, all-tube, standard-def, CRT TV he's trying to sell to someone like that).
 
What resistor can possibly be so critical, in a guitar pedal context, that it can't be found, closely enough, in the widely available, el-cheapo, 1%/E96 series? 🤔
And who still uses carbon resistors? (asking for a friend who has a vintage, B&W, all-tube, standard-def, CRT TV he's trying to sell to someone like that).
I was thinking such a hack might be useful for getting the precise value used in testing Ge BJTs for gain and leakage ala the the Keen Germanium Transistor Testor which calls for a 2K472 value resistor.
 
I was thinking such a hack might be useful for getting the precise value used in testing Ge BJTs for gain and leakage ala the the Keen Germanium Transistor Testor which calls for a 2K472 value resistor.
You made me look it up. What about the meter's input impedance? Assuming it's as high as 1Meg, that would already turn the 2.472k resistor into more like 2.466k.
 
I’ve never heard of this resistor value hack before. Seems legit considering it only increases resistance.

Anyone else have experience with this procedure?

View attachment 49222
A buddy of mine worked as a tech in the precision resistor business a zillion years ago, mostly for telecom and miltary applications. He would hand trim metal film resistor sets frequently, using a few different methods. A Dremel tool and epoxy was often involved, but for more critical applications they had some kind of helical grinder, which ported to laser trimming at some point.

My personal experience was mostly with being given thousands of out of spec but very closely matched pieces, sometimes in nice neat multiples of values as well. Resistors with 0.1% or better tolerance were not common back then, and definitely not for small money.
 
Back
Top