I keep a simple text document of stuff I like and a "Short-List" at the top of the doc.
When I purchase something, it goes from black text to pink; when I receive it, I change the text colour to green.
The colour-coding helps me keep track of what's what and prevents unwanted repeat purchases of the same circuit.
As stuff gets greenlit, it goes back into the main list, so the Short-list is constantly evolving.
I'd probably use a Wish-list feature on the site, but I wouldn't give up my simple-text doc system.
Added a new colour to my simple doc list, golden yellow for the "Coming Soon" items.
I forgot to mention I organise each category with 5 items, then a line break. Grouping in 5s is easier on the eyes and helps find items more quickly.
For the PedalPCB dirt category... I gave up. I tried to keep a complete list but it's simply too big a list for my little filing system.

I'll probably give the Dirt section its own document, and further sub-categorise the dirt — which is difficult when one pedal can be in "Boost", "OD" and "DISTORTION"...
Had I not come back to update with the new colour, I'd probably have missed that the PPCB Wishlist is active, I didn't even notice it!
THANKS Mr PedalPCB for the WishList!
Okay, off to make with the wishing...