So I just bought a pound of Kester 24-6337-0027. This is 63/37, with the semi-corrosive rosin core. This is the same as what I was previously using too. It has the semi-corrosive rosin core, so definitely not no-clean. It is annoying to clean, it’s like pine tar, really gooey and sticky.
Before I bought it, I did a little research, and the impression I got is that the no-clean stuff is no-clean because the rosin flux is non-corrosive. While corrosive sounds bad, it’s actually beneficial in some cases, particularly if the work itself is already dirty, corroded, and/or oxidized. The corrosive effect of the flux helps clean away the mess, making for a better solder joint. I’m paraphrasing from memory, so that may not be quite precise. But the gist I got is that ideally the no-clean stuff should only be used on clean “virgin” work, and can be suboptimal for re-work.
I think populating a new PCB is probably the ideal case for the no-clean solder. But my thinking was, it’s not uncommon that I do re-work, so the corrosive should-clean stuff is more general.
But now I’m thinking I’ll just keep both on hand, because cleaning is a PITA.
Also: thoughts on Chip Quik vs Kester? I’ve gone with Kester because that seems to get parroted the most in solder recommendation discussions, but I’m open to others.