Question about SPINCAD (audio)

HarryR

New member
Hi,

I like the SPINCAD designer.

What I'm missing is a possibility to use "live-audio-data" i.e. why is using microphone input as audio source not implemented ?

I ask, because I'd try to implement it if there's no "special reason" why it wasn't implemented up to now ?

Best regards
Harry
 
Hi,

I like the SPINCAD designer.

What I'm missing is a possibility to use "live-audio-data" i.e. why is using microphone input as audio source not implemented ?

I ask, because I'd try to implement it if there's no "special reason" why it wasn't implemented up to now ?

Best regards
Harry
The original "SpinCAD Designer" app (from @Digital Larry at Holy City Audio) never implemented a 'live' input option. Robert's brand-new web-based "SpinCad Web" app does.

And important to note: Robert's SpinCAD Web app has added a new feature (design block - specifically: the 'Frequency Shift' block in the Modulation group) that will not work in Digital Larry's SpinCAD Designer, so the files created in Robert's SpinCAD Web app may NOT work in Digital Larry's SpinCAD Designer.
 
Last edited:
The original "SpinCAD Designer" app (from Digital Larry at Holy City Audio) never implemented a 'live' input option. Robert's brand-new web-based "SpinCad Web" app does.

And important to note: Robert's SpinCAD Web app has added a new feature (design block - specifically: the 'Frequency Shift' block in the Modulation group) that will not work in Digital Larry's SpinCAD Designer, so the files created in Robert's SpinCAD Web app may NOT work in Digital Larry's SpinCAD Designer.
Well I didn't know there's a web client .. Anyway I'm talking about Larrys program :-)
 
That's Digital Larry's "SpinCAD Designer" app. It does NOT have that feature. Use Robert's brand-new web-based "SpinCad Web" app.
Yes :-) I think I have to wait for Larry's comment. I think implementing soundcard input should not be too difficult,
but I wait for a comment from Larry - maybe he sees kind of major (design) problems
 
And important to note: Robert's SpinCAD Web app has added a new feature (design block - specifically: the 'Frequency Shift' block in the Modulation group) that will not work in Digital Larry's SpinCAD Designer, so the files created in Robert's SpinCAD Web app may NOT work in Digital Larry's SpinCAD Designer.

As of right now they are backwards compatible as long as none of the new blocks are used.
 
Hi everyone, thanks for the interest in SpinCAD.

I did not design the FV-1 simulator code that SpinCAD is built upon. That was Andrew Kilpatrick of Kilpatrick Audio. I didn't implement a live audio input because:
a) I didn't know how to, off the top of my head
b) A tool like Claude was not available when I did the original development in 2012
c) I didn't care that much, although obviously I see the utility

At this point in time, I have very little motivation to touch SpinCAD again. Now that Robert is taking it to new places I am OK anointing him to be the maintainer of the tool-du-jour. Robert has a vested interest in this because he sells a product that can use it. I don't have any such motivation and I have other things I want to do in my spare time. 95% of my contributions in the past few years came from @Cybercow and it started to make me feel bad.

Finally, SpinCAD is open source and anyone can fork it and add features and so on, but only a few people have done this. Several have apparently used SpinCAD for inspiration and taken it to new places such as a VS Code plugin or Robert's web tool. It's all fine.

For the few times I have wanted to make FV-1 patches recently, I just use Claude directly.

I hope this helps!

DL
 
Last edited:
Back
Top