TC1 (aka the Chinese tester) useless for measuring GE diode Vf?

flemming

Well-known member
I was checking the Vf of some D9E diodes that I had and the numbers I was getting were way off, so I checked them with my DMM and got something more reasonable. I started testing a bunch of different diodes and here's what I found:

ComponentDMM (HT118A)TC1Difference
3mm Red LED1.761.91+8.5%
5mm Green LED1.902.05+8.0%
1N5817.213.266+25%
1N4148.611.705+15.9%
1N34A.280.386+38%
D9E.308.510+66%
D9K.276.406+47%

As with measuring anything with two different tools, they of course don't match. But the differences get quite a bit bigger when testing GE diodes. Given that the 1N5817 is off as well perhaps it's just accuracy at lower voltages. Has anyone else seen this or is mine just junkier than the usual junk? Is the moral of the story, cheap things are cheap?

Robert
 
No it's fine and totally normal the Chinese tester is just hitting them with a higher current and you're seeing a different point on the curve. Look at a diode curve trace and you'll see what I mean.
 
The green band 1n34a and some tfk 1n34a go much higher than the d9e and d9k. I'll test some later and post my results for you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fig
Here's some of mine measured on a T7 tester.

DMM first then component tester

D9E 0.237 - 518mv
D9B 0.228 - 387mv
D9K 0.226 - 404mv
1n60 0.234 - 660mv
1n34a 0.261 - 694mv - TFK black band
1n34a 0.270 - 713mv - green band
1n34a 0.236 - 664mv - double black band tayda
Unknown germ 0.224 - 997mv unknown tayda germanium
 
  • Like
Reactions: fig
Back
Top