Most of 'em meet the Vp and Idss spec for 2N5457. I have not measured gfs yet.
Bummer that you forgot to take your breadboard on vacation. I had that happen once and I feel your pain.
Looks like the drain voltage is too low in your sim. What's the input amplitude?Never again...
But.... while drinking afternoon coffee I played a little bit with ltspice.
This is my modified first stage. In order to keep frequency response more or less intact I removed R13 and C9, increased C1 and C2, lowered C3.
View attachment 14352 View attachment 14353View attachment 14354