I actually like the Mod Podge Dishwasher safe glue better than the original glue. There's still a learning curve with the whole transfer process, but it seems more forgiving than the original W1+ glue.
Here's the last pedal I built using the Sunnyscopa film-free waterslide decal paper and Mod Podge Dishwasher Safe glue. Awesome pedal by the way.
Thanks! I haven't tried transferring to bare aluminum, only Tayda powder coated enclosures. It's important to first prep the enclosure surface. I do a quick wipe with alcohol soaked paper towel beforehand. The last few times I used the film-free decals, I went to FedEx Office and used their laser printer/copier. I've had to experiment with the paper thickness settings to get the proper amount of ink. There's a Zen to how much Mod Podge to apply; too much, and it's messy and doesn't transfer properly; if you don't use enough, there's nothing in between the enclosure and the transfer sheet to grab onto the ink, plus it's hard to slide the sheet into proper position. Also, I try to leave somewhere between 1/8" to 1/4" of the sheet overhanging towards one end of the enclosure so I can grab it to peel off.So I bought this dishwasher save Mod Podge, and tried it with the Sunnyscopa film-free laserjet paper. It didn't really work, I got less than 50% transfer of toner to the enclosure. I was using a bare aluminum enclosure that I'd sanded with 180 grit sandpaper, using an orbital sander. I followed the same application process I described here, using the Mod Podge instead of the Sunnyscopa transfer aid. I did a 15ish minute drying in the toaster oven at 225F.
After that failed, I re-sanded the enclosures and used the GW1-PRO glue, and got a perfect transfer. (The GW1-PRO has generally been pretty good for me on bare aluminum enclosures).
Your pedal looks great, you clearly got 100% transfer. Did your process differ compared to what I described?
I do believe there may be something to the hair dryer treatment. The hot air is very direct on the transfer sheet. I can't actually see it happening, but I'm pretty sure the direct heat is releasing the ink onto the enclosure. I've had some failures with the hair dryer method, where I wasn't holding it close enough and/or moving too fast, but after some trial and error, I believe I have a fairly solid methodology to it. I always have some acetone ready for the inevitable screw-ups, but most of the time it turns out decent. You may want to give it a shot.You used a hair dryer, where I used a toaster oven, but unless you managed to hit some magic "Goldilocks" temperature, I don't feel that's a major difference.
I do believe there may be something to the hair dryer treatment. The hot air is very direct on the transfer sheet. I can't actually see it happening, but I'm pretty sure the direct heat is releasing the ink onto the enclosure. I've had some failures with the hair dryer method, where I wasn't holding it close enough and/or moving too fast, but after some trial and error, I believe I have a fairly solid methodology to it. I always have some acetone ready for the inevitable screw-ups, but most of the time it turns out decent. You may want to give it a shot.