I wouldn't compare these 2 circuits, first time I have heard of the Guyatone mentioned!"Median compressor" ?
I really thought PPCB was releasing a clone of Guyatone PS-21 like Aion's Meridian compressor !
Tl072 or JRC4558? or something less common?IC1 - IC4 OP1678 is only available in SOIC-8 SMD package.
A through-hole adapter pictured above can be used, or a low-noise dual opamp with similar specs can be used as a substitute.
For comps, it's a pretty good idea to stick to the lowest noise opamp you can. (The 072 was low noise for it's time but opamps have gotten a lot better)Tl072 or JRC4558? or something less common?
ah, so maybe the OPA2134? I've used that in a couple pedals but I don't have ton on hand since they're like 6 bucks a pop.For comps, it's a pretty good idea to stick to the lowest noise opamp you can. (The 072 was low noise for it's time but opamps have gotten a lot better)
Reason being, however much gain reduction you are getting, you then have to make up that gain. The self noise of each opamp stage is going to increased by that makeup gain. As comps are usually very early in the chain, that noise is further amplified by any clipping(and more make up gain) further down the signal chain.
@JTEX , being the noise floor chaser he is, can probably chime in with some recommendations. I'd at least spec it with a readily available OPA through hole part though.
It's a double edged sword with pedals. They're inherently low fidelity. But in non-clipping situations, I try to be mindful of the noise. Higher quality(lower noise) opamps, no mlccs in the signal path, quality low ESR electros if they have to be in the signal path.ah, so maybe the OPA2134? I've used that in a couple pedals but I don't have ton on hand since they're like 6 bucks a pop.
I literally just this morning started thinking about paying better attention to component quality. Upgrading the opamps from the BoM was one idea, so this is very top of mind.
Thanks!
Note, he's talking about onboard buffers...As usual, I am of the strong opinion that TL072 has no business being in a top notch guitar buffer in 2023. It's just too noisy at 18nV/sqrt(Hz) (same as the thermal noise of a 20k resistor). I would pick something with less than half that noise. And of course, it would also have to have very low current noise to do well with high impedance sources, so either JFET input or super beta bipolar (my new favorite). My best suggestions as a guitar buffer: OPA205/206/207, OPA145. Or, if you have all the money and want the quietest possible op amp that can handle high source Z, get an OPA827, or even two of them in parallel if you're nuts (I am, and I've done it).
this is super helpful! differentiating use cases is really important and makes a lot of sense to me. same regarding caps in the signal path. a couple pedals I've made have been noisier than I'd like, so having some ideas around that is great.It's a double edged sword with pedals. They're inherently low fidelity. But in non-clipping situations, I try to be mindful of the noise. Higher quality(lower noise) opamps, no mlccs in the signal path, quality low ESR electros if they have to be in the signal path.
But that's just me. No right or wrong. It just helps me sleep less badder. But I would advise keeping noise in mind at the front end of your signal chain(compressors, buffers, clean boosts). Here's a good one from JTEX
Note, he's talking about onboard buffers...
"Median compressor" ?
I really thought PPCB was releasing a clone of Guyatone PS-21 like Aion's Meridian compressor !
Can't answer your questions but 2N5457 have been obsolete for some time so they may be fake? MMBF5457 is the SMD equivalent, these are still widely available and can be used with adapter boards.I've just built this, but I haven't put it into an enclosure or attached the switch and jacks, yet.
I'm curious about the 2N5457 Transistors. How do I measure them to make sure they're good for the build?
I have a T7 tester, but it's been acting funny. Most of the 2N5457's I'm trying to measure are just coming up as resistors. It was doing this the other day with a few BC108C's I got from Stomp box parts, too. The BC108C's were coming up as two diodes.
Is the tester the problem, or did I get bad transistors?
Can I check them by hooking up the pedal and using a multimeter?
Also, is the trim pot there to bias the transistors? If so, do I just set them to 4.5V?
Thanks!