Yes, you could probably use either one of those, but why don't you try salvaging the one with the solder in the hole. There are four things you can do (actually probably more than that, but I'm going to give you four options here).
1. Heat the pad, and stick a toothpick through the hole - the toothpick won't bond to the pad, and you can pull it out leaving the hole open.
2. Heat up the pad, and just stick the wire through. This is my favorite option -- super simple, no fuss way to get a component into a hole that has solder in it -- (works best with solid core wire)
3. Use a solder sucker. If you have a solder sucker, it's pretty easy to stand the pcb vertically in a clamp, and apply heat to one side of the pad, while getting a good flush connections with the solder sucker to the other side of the pad, and POW -- one click of the thumb press and the hole is nice and clean and ready for a fresh insertion (phrasing).
4. Use some solder wick -- I'll admit that this isn't the best option (sometimes makes more of a mess that it fixes). It is an option.