Guitar playing- learning songs

Ok so I wasn’t going to chime in on this but learning song can definitely be a good way to learn I know that’s exactly how I started, and it’s by far the best introduction to the instrument because it can be so frustrating to learn but I have found my first student to be a natural..


This was one of my first video edits I did about 4 years ago that I don’t think I have shown too many people but seems like a fitting thread and why keep this little gem all to myself… it was just good fun.

If this doesn’t convince you that you guys take me to seriously nothing will.
You had me… then I realized you’re left handed… so you are dead to me…

JK, this is awesome!
 
I wanted to learn this for a while and it ended up being way easier than I was expecting. I also figured out after I recorded this how to set my phone's camera to not dogshit resolution
that’s awesome! I love it! Makes me want a tele How did you get your rez better YouTube always seems to kill mine for some reason and I never figured out why.
 
I wanted to learn this for a while and it ended up being way easier than I was expecting. I also figured out after I recorded this how to set my phone's camera to not dogshit resolution
LOVED IT!

I have a lot of... history, with this song.

In my youth I had a crew-chief who always played the country station, of which 99% of the music I hated at the time — the guy was a complete dick-asshole-supreme, which made me loath ... everything.

One day, a song came on that made me laugh, it had a musical joke in it, a twang that infected my brain — Pete Anderson's little bend, and I loved it. I then took some guitar-lessons for a red-hot 30 seconds and my most excellent-teacher taught this poor-student the lick and solo — about the only thing I stuck around long-enough to learn. It's still one of the few things that I still know how to strangle and almost always do so when I pick up a guitar.

I'd show you how I mangle it, but ...
a) nobody should be subjected to my geetar-sleighing [sic];
b) I'm not set up for viddying.
 
What is you guys' approach to learning songs? By ear, tab, in-person instruction, YouTube, ??? So many of my guitar heroes seemed to learn by ear (since most of them came well before the Internet), so I feel like that is how I should learn songs. And I can learn by ear, to a somewhat limited extent (depending on the song). I usually have to slow things down quite a bit (I use this Transcribe! software for that). But unless it's an easy three or four cowboy chord song, it's usually a pretty slow process. And the more complex chords that are used, the harder it gets for me. I haven't even tried to work out a shreddy/technical fast solo, but I can usually work out single-note runs reasonably well (albeit slowly). I'm sure it gets easier with practice, it's just one of those things that requires a fair amount of dedicated time (and I consider myself "time poor").

When I want to learn something quickly, I usually turn to the web. But I've increasingly found that Internet tab - at least the free stuff - tends to be atrocious more often than not. But there are a few YouTube guys that seem to have consistently good breakdowns of how to play a song.

My father-in-law has been playing piano since he was three (he also plays guitar). He and I were learning some songs just to jam together for fun when we're visiting. He literally sat down and learned these songs by ear as he was listening to them! That was truly impressive, but also somewhat discouraging, because the contrast to how long it takes me to do the same is staggering.
 
What is you guys' approach to learning songs?
Youtube is my primary resource for learning most things. I'd like to know more songs. It takes a kind of focus that I'm lacking a lot of the time though. I'm more likely to put on a Youtube backing track and go to noodle-town. Might be atrocious to listen to, but it's something I can do while being zoned out and relaxed, and at least I'm playing.

For actual song breakdowns this guy is my favorite. Most of the time his pace seems about right for me, and he seems pretty thorough about studying the source material and trying to get an accurate version together.

 
What is you guys' approach to learning songs? By ear, tab, in-person instruction, YouTube, ??? So many of my guitar heroes seemed to learn by ear (since most of them came well before the Internet), so I feel like that is how I should learn songs. And I can learn by ear, to a somewhat limited extent (depending on the song). I usually have to slow things down quite a bit (I use this Transcribe! software for that). But unless it's an easy three or four cowboy chord song, it's usually a pretty slow process. And the more complex chords that are used, the harder it gets for me. I haven't even tried to work out a shreddy/technical fast solo, but I can usually work out single-note runs reasonably well (albeit slowly). I'm sure it gets easier with practice, it's just one of those things that requires a fair amount of dedicated time (and I consider myself "time poor").

When I want to learn something quickly, I usually turn to the web. But I've increasingly found that Internet tab - at least the free stuff - tends to be atrocious more often than not. But there are a few YouTube guys that seem to have consistently good breakdowns of how to play a song.

My father-in-law has been playing piano since he was three (he also plays guitar). He and I were learning some songs just to jam together for fun when we're visiting. He literally sat down and learned these songs by ear as he was listening to them! That was truly impressive, but also somewhat discouraging, because the contrast to how long it takes me to do the same is staggering.
I learn a lot by ear. I know most of a song's lyrics and chord changes after 1-3 listens. For solos and stuff, I mostly use YouTube so I can slow it down to 50% to pick out subtle things
 
Ear training is a separate skill to work on, both in parallel and in conjunction with your guitar playing skills. Your father in law has probably been using his ear to learn and play music for longer than a lot of people have been alive. I have played alongside and with some great guitarists and it is easy to be discouraged by that when you start comparing yourself to them. A perspective shift might be in order: it is a great opportunity to learn from better musicians than yourself. No matter how good you are, there are always bigger fish in the pond. Promise yourself that you will practice harder because of it. Use it as an excuse to play more, not less.

For me, I have a decent ear. If a song is moderately complex, I can do it by ear most of the time, while double checking my work against what other people on the internet have found. Often times it is easier and quicker to do this than to find a half correct tab written up by someone from a decade ago. If it's a very complex song, I will try by my ear for a few bars, then give and watch a proper tutorial hahah.
 
I had a little time today so I decided that play along with songs I hadn't played along to in ages. Mainly a bunch of old CAKE songs and a little Elvis Costello.

I've been trying to be a bit more intentional about playing. Less noodling and more doing, and playing along with songs is a good way to work my way back into that, I think. It was a good time, I'll have to record myself playing along to something one of these days.

Nevermind the mess!

PXL_20231106_004208620.jpg
 
I had a little time today so I decided that play along with songs I hadn't played along to in ages. Mainly a bunch of old CAKE songs and a little Elvis Costello.

I've been trying to be a bit more intentional about playing. Less noodling and more doing, and playing along with songs is a good way to work my way back into that, I think. It was a good time, I'll have to record myself playing along to something one of these days.

Nevermind the mess!

View attachment 59935
I like that maple leaf ya got there
 
Back
Top