Is that little black treadle secured to the pot shaft good? Sometimes certain ones can come loose and it will spin without turning the pot shaft. If it's not that I'd check the wiring to the pot again. Sounds like the switch and switch wiring is ok. If everything looks perfect it could possibly be a broken trace under the top layer of the PCB. Happened to me a couple times but it's an easy fix once you find it.I made the short video to show that effect is active, but no wah effect when moving the pedal.