Silver Blues
Well-known member
I would agree, in a vacuum, with the statement that "not all advertising is bad". The issue is the constant bombardment of annoying and irrelevant advertisements, and moreover, the fact that those advertisements brazenly intrude upon and aggressively obfuscate your interaction with the actual media you are trying to consume.
I don't mind, for example, when a YouTube channel I follow takes a calculated break at a convenient time in their own video to advertise a product they themselves endorse. This doesn't feel like a violation and incites way less rage than SCREAMING ADVERTISEMENTS ABOUT THINGS YOU HAVE NO INTEREST IN BEFORE YOU'RE ALLOWED TO WATCH THE VIDEO AND NO YOU CAN'T SKIP THEM AND FUCK YOU IF YOU USE AN ADBLOCKER TO MAINTAIN A SHRED OF SANITY.
So, in the same vein, your ideas above would not be as poorly received, as long as the whole site wasn't plastered with banner ads that distract from the actual content. That said, people like me would probably never see them anyway (adblockers), so YMMV.
I don't mind, for example, when a YouTube channel I follow takes a calculated break at a convenient time in their own video to advertise a product they themselves endorse. This doesn't feel like a violation and incites way less rage than SCREAMING ADVERTISEMENTS ABOUT THINGS YOU HAVE NO INTEREST IN BEFORE YOU'RE ALLOWED TO WATCH THE VIDEO AND NO YOU CAN'T SKIP THEM AND FUCK YOU IF YOU USE AN ADBLOCKER TO MAINTAIN A SHRED OF SANITY.
So, in the same vein, your ideas above would not be as poorly received, as long as the whole site wasn't plastered with banner ads that distract from the actual content. That said, people like me would probably never see them anyway (adblockers), so YMMV.