That's basically how I think of them tbh. Any circuit I've tried them in has sounded pants and has had virtually no gain/drive e.g. a plexi drive etc I don't know if they're fake or just out of spec parts
I did measure them using the improved jfet matcher on tagboard effects ages ago and from memory they were technically in spec but only just. I'll pop a few onto the transistor tester shortly and let you know.
I chucked a couple in the transistor tester I just bought and have put the results below. I can breadboard the one from tagboard effects again later if this isn't helpful
1 -
ID = 0.25mA
VG = 172mV
2 -
ID = 0.36mA
VG = 254mV
3 -
ID = 0.44mA
VG = 307mV
4 -
ID = 0.15mA
VG = 106mV
Yes I have done it before a long time ago and they checked out as being in spec but literally only just. I don't think they're fake to be honest but I do think they're rejects which have been resold. I bought them shortly after I started building pedals in 2015ish when I didn't know any better.