It seems long shaft 500k reverse log pots are not as common as the regular ones but I did find some here:
Our customers kept asking us, “Why doesn't anyone have left-handed CTS Long Shaft pots?” Well, here ya go! True Reverse Audio Taper 3/4" Brass Bushing 24 Spline "fine" knurled, split shaft Ideal replacement potentiometers for many post-1973 Gibson Les Paul models, and other USA- made, thick...
www.nachomusic.com
They also have .022uf orange drop caps, which is what it seems all the 50's wiring harnesses come with. I don't know what the guitar has currently so I should probably get new ones. Are these fine?:
.022uf ±5%, 200V, Great Clarity Made using the finest polypropylene film Tinned copper-clad leads Proven reliability As of October 2012, Cornell Dubilier has taken over production of Orange Drop capacitors from Sprague. As a result, your capacitor may be marked with either SBE or CDE.
www.nachomusic.com
Or these are way expensive - eek!:
Made in USA - Oil filled, Kraft paper and extended foil construction - Sealed with epoxy resin end-fills - 24 AWG, Tin-coated, oxygen-free copper - Tolerance ±5% - Wax potted coating for a classic finish
www.nachomusic.com
Am I going to hear a difference? Or is that one of those forever debated topics?