at last
View attachment 116787
funnily enough, this one was quite a troublemaker
View attachment 116785
this took me much longer to get a handle on and running properly than it took for a Boss HM-2 or even the MT-2 - both more than twice the size of this circuit.
didn't help that I initially started with a fake TA7136 (got my refund)
View attachment 116788
but that’s not the worst of it.
i’m kinda shocked the problems this bastard circuit has isn’t talked about more, particularly the DS-1A / post-1994 version with dual opamp. fortunately at least one person here posted a
DIYSB link that covers this issue.
initially I was referring to the aionfx comet
legacy schematic, which unfortunately suggests you can just plop in a 4558 or equivalent...
but you can't, unless you move this diode:
View attachment 116789
View attachment 116790
IME, with the diode in stock position (+/non-inverting input to ground), that spicy signal coming off Q2 absolutely slams the opamp, in a way that makes it sound like a HM-2 doing the chainsaw thing, and not in a good way - if you play gentle it doesn't happen, if you play normally it sorta swells in and out. fucking awful.
i also made an odd discovery that I'm still yet to understand:
- if you skip the input buffer, and hook up the guitar input directly to C2/47n, this problem disappears! wtf... cool! but that didn't sound like a reasonable solution, and i was convinced I had made an error somewhere..
before I had found this advice above, i was stumped.
noting the advice above about opamp selection, i confirmed this with an LM358 - works fine with stock configuration.
RC4580, 4558, LF353 -> absolutely fucked with the stock configuration, and all worked well with the diode between (+) & (-) inputs
little bit disappointed that aionfx has not corrected the comet legacy document with it's misleading advice. the updated/current comet document has corrected this but still, ffs..
noting comments about the redundancy of this 1st opamp/buffer stage in the dual opamp version, i was curious to try out a single opamp version with a KR140UD708 (soviet LM741 equivalent) and set up the breadboard to accommodate both 741 and 4558 for direct swap/comparison.
and then after finding this service manual with schematics for the x2 versions, I had to explore both.
honestly, the OG/pre-1994 version kinda sucks (for me). the larger cap values (1U v 470n; 470n v 68n) make for a flubby response.
yes, im not using the correct TA7136 opamp to assess it properly, but I'm not convinced it would rectify those issues.
I'm going to assume folks that prefer the early version are single coil players.
with the DS-1A values, comparing KR140UD708/LM741 to 4558, i wanted to like the 741, but the 4558 had more volume, punch, and high end detail, where the 741 was smoother, more polite, and a smidge less gain.
with this information, I would probably recommend the 741 for those that prefer a more 'vintage-inspired' DS-1, and the 4558 for those that like a more modern/full spectrum response.
here's my demo (DS-1A version w/ 4558)
surprisingly beefy. gain is cranked up to about 80-90% on the trimpot, so there is a touch of 'sag' going on..
next steps - will have to try some of CDB's mods --> particularly the one with 470R/2U2 for Q2s emitter.. (im not really into the sag)
View attachment 116795