szukalski
Well-known member
It's a great layout. The only thing I could think to improve mine was to make the 5V an IO pad as well, in case you need it for some reason.I'm pretty happy with how this one has turned out.
It's a great layout. The only thing I could think to improve mine was to make the 5V an IO pad as well, in case you need it for some reason.I'm pretty happy with how this one has turned out.
Not sure what you mean. Do they not stay static on the page after you click the measurement you want?
Aren't the resdef / values on the wrong sides? Ie. you need values on the front for population, and the rear for troubleshooting.Just sent this one off to JLC:
View attachment 78743
I had the reverse issue up until you mentioned it: I did not even k ow there was a measuring tool.
The dimension tool is so much more useful I must have glossed right over it.
They’re on the right side for my workflow. I like to follow the schematic as I populate the PCB, so it’s easier for me if I keep the refdes on the top silkscreen layer. Additionally, for octave fuzzes with a differential pair like this one, I like to match the resistors in the octave section (R7-12, R15, R16) as closely as my Fluke will allow. This actually makes a big difference to my ears, and results in a stronger octave than just using a trimpot for the differential pair’s base to ground resistors. So for a circuit like this, it’s nice to be able to identify which 1k/10k/22k resistors need to be matched without having to flip over the board. The reason that I started putting values on the back is to serve as a backup of sorts in case the schematic is ever lost, rather than for ease of assembly on my part.Aren't the resdef / values on the wrong sides? Ie. you need values on the front for population, and the rear for troubleshooting.
Since you're rolling your own boards, have you considered resistors arrays? 0.05% matched are just a few bucks.They’re on the right side for my workflow. I like to follow the schematic as I populate the PCB, so it’s easier for me if I keep the refdes on the top silkscreen layer. Additionally, for octave fuzzes with a differential pair like this one, I like to match the resistors in the octave section (R7-12, R15, R16) as closely as my Fluke will allow. This actually makes a big difference to my ears, and results in a stronger octave than just using a trimpot for the differential pair’s base to ground resistors. So for a circuit like this, it’s nice to be able to identify which 1k/10k/22k resistors need to be matched without having to flip over the board. The reason that I started putting values on the back is to serve as a backup of sorts in case the schematic is ever lost, rather than for ease of assembly on my part.
Definitely takes all the fun out of it. Plus there are diminishing returns going from ±0.5% to ±0.05%. But an interesting idea for future use for sure.Since you're rolling your own boards, have you considered resistors arrays? 0.05% matched are just a few bucks.
Or maybe that takes the fun out of it.
Thanks for all the tips, I definitely need to rework the power supply section.Congrats on making the leap! A few thoughts/questions:
- I'd recommend changing the polarity protection diode to a series diode, rather than the parallel diode to ground. A series diode is more reliable.
- I'm not sure if I'm reading the symbols correctly, but it also looks like your indicator LED is not connected to a switch pad and will always be on.
- Does the box with "IN G 9v OUT" represents four pads for wiring the footswitch? If so, you'll probably want to remove the 9v pad and replace it with a switch pad that connects to the cathode of the indicator LED.
- The clipping LEDs look questionable to me. A single transistor into a tonestack seems unlikely to produce a hot enough signal to reach the clipping threshold of the LEDs. I'd recommend moving them after the 1uF capacitor that follows the second transistor. you have a hot enough signal to clip the red clipping LEDs?
- What is the -9V(T) net? It looks like it's the same as ground.
- What is the difference between GND and GND(T)?
- Which potentiometers are external controls? Which ones are internal trimmers?
It’s possible that there is DC that’s making them blink. Try putting a large capacitor between them and the rest of the signal path and see if they still pulse.Thanks for all the tips, I definitely need to rework the power supply section.
The clipping LEDs occasionally pulse while I'm playing, so I assume they're working?
Gotcha. I use V- or DC- for that pad on my schematics. It might be worth changing the name because the negative connection is 0v, not -9v.-9V(T) is the pad for the negative connection from the DC jack, I wasn't sure how to represent connecting it to ground, so that's what I came up with.
I’d recommend keeping both refdes and values in your schematics. It’s difficult to discuss the schematic without refuses, and it’s hard to know what the circuit is doing without values. Check out the schematics that I’ve posted (or the schematics in the PedalPCB build docs, for that matter) for examples of schematics that include both.Maybe I'll try to find some example schematics where everything is shown, usually that stuff seems to be omitted. I do have everything labeled on the schematic, but turned off refdes and justed showed values for the print image because it wouldn't all fit, but I realize now it would've been more helpful to leave the labels on and the values off. Thanks again, I'll get back to work on this tomorrow!
- The clipping LEDs look questionable to me. A single transistor into a tonestack seems unlikely to produce a hot enough signal to reach the clipping threshold of the LEDs. I'd recommend moving them after the 1uF capacitor that follows the second transistor. you have a hot enough signal to clip the red clipping LEDs?
The clipping LEDs occasionally pulse while I'm playing, so I assume they're working? They're just there to prevent hard clipping from the jfets.