Nostradoomus
Well-known member
I have an e bike for commuting so I’m not really a recreational cyclist, it is kick ass though. After owning it for 5 months I realized it has a throttle and I don’t have to actually pedal all the time. 
Yeah eBikes. I cycle for work each day . EBikes are all around here. Nobody asked my opinion on it but I think a flag should be mandatory:I have an e bike for commuting so I’m not really a recreational cyclist, it is kick ass though. After owning it for 5 months I realized it has a throttle and I don’t have to actually pedal all the time.![]()
Well, without rampant diabetes and mass shootings, something has to thin the herd. (Joke)We have a lot of accidents with fatbikes and elderly in EBikes in the Netherlands.
Yep, this is what they're calling "all-road" these days, and is a really versatile setup. Renegade S3 is a pretty nice spec and that price is really not bad at all. Midnight Special is a cult classic in this segment (and the Midnight Special frame was actually on my shortlist when I made my own bike decision) though Surlys don't tend to build up very lightweight (you will absolutely notice the benefit of a lighter-weight bike, and any steel-framed bike will never be as lightweight as an all-carbon race rig, but for riders like us, this does not matter as much as the industry wants us to believe. The difference between a 35-40lb department-store bike and a 26-27lb reasonably priced decent bike is much more than the difference between my 23lb Fog Cutter and my 18lb Felt F5 wannabe race rig.)
The selling points of the 1x setup are 1) simplified shifting logic (you only have to worry about one derailleur, and the more robust one to boot, and the options are "up" and "down"), 2) fewer moving parts and cables, which means 3) lighter and 4) easier to maintain. You lose on range (because fewer chainrings) which is compensated for with bigger cassettes, but there is no free lunch, because fitting a 400% gearing range on a single cassette means larger gaps between gears, which is not so good for road riding (where you want to be able to respond to grade changes with subtle adjustments). But, many people prefer the 1x for the aforementioned reasons. There are some old-school riders that swear 3x9 is the best drivetrain, and I see the argument - 9-speed components are extremely robust and (even still) widely available and you get an excellent gearing range without going to massive cassettes or tiny chainrings. But, triple cranks are heavy as shit, there are many duplicate or nearly-duplicate gearing ratios, and cross-chaining (unreasonable lateral bending of the chain in gear combinations on opposite ends of the crank and cassette) is a much bigger issue. Modern wisdom says mountain and rough gravel go 1x and pure-road or all-road go 2x. A useful gearing range for most "real" riders is a 1:1 or less low gear and at most a 4:1 high gear; unless you are a very strong rider, bias downwards given the choice (realistically you aren't going to be pedaling at 45 or 50 kph, but you might hit an ass-kicking climb with little notice).Both cool lookin rigs! Seems like that set up with a single up front and a huge wide range cassette is a hot thing these days, but I haven’t looked into it to figure out why. Do you know the deal with those? Any preference on that vs a triple?
I fully intend on responding to individuals parts of this post in more detail later, but this is incredible and I am 100% here for the wall of text.You guys made a fucking mistake letting me see this thread because now you're gonna get a wall of text![]()
$1300??? For the whole bike? Holy shit, I paid 90% of that for the frame and fork alone. I'd jump on it, I daresay you'll not want to give it back once you try it!I fully intend on responding to individuals parts of this post in more detail later, but this is incredible and I am 100% here for the wall of text.
Also, I saw that my local shop has a Soma Fog Cutter for $1300. Definitely piqued my interest prior to your post, gonna go try it out when I’ve got free time!
Yea it's for the whole bike, I'll post a picture of it below. It looks super clean, although I think it might be set up as more of a "commuter" type ride than a recreational/exercise-y type bike (tbh it probably won't make that much of a difference though), and I'm not sure how I feel about the shifters being those lever style ones at the end of the handlebar. Either way though I'm going to give it a test ride soon and see how I like it.$1300??? For the whole bike? Holy shit, I paid 90% of that for the frame and fork alone. I'd jump on it, I daresay you'll not want to give it back once you try it!
First off, this is a BEAUTIFUL bike and I'm very jealous. That all blue frame is doing something to me.I had one put together myself recently, Soma Fog Cutter v2, and I am adoring the ride:
View attachment 95861
The disc brake vs rim brake is still a hotly contested issue. The gap narrows at the high end (and the makers of these neo-retro types of frames I am describing have become very good at making a very nice rim brake frame) but I am in camp "disc brakes forever for any reason" and would recommend you look for a bike that has them.
I have a 3x9 set up currently and find myself sitting on the biggest gear on the chainring and making smaller adjustments to the rear gears. 90% of the time that works for me, and then the other 10% I'll plop it down to the smallest gear set if I'm going up a steep hill. Will probably be looking for some kind of 2x setup since I like having that versatility and while most of my riding is on flat roads, there are some hills that I encounter on a regular basis.. There are some old-school riders that swear 3x9 is the best drivetrain, and I see the argument -
What size tire do you use? And what kind of riding do you do primarily? I think the all-road setup appeals to me but worry that it'll feel way more sluggish than my road bike. Although to be honest, the 650b setup of that Midnight Special seemed like it would be a lot of fun to tool around on.Yep, this is what they're calling "all-road" these days, and is a really versatile setup.
... the most important thing is that the bike fits you properly. A $900 bike that fits you is better than a $10k bike that doesn't.
This is just the opening salvo. Next up - Build Reports of our latest steeds. Troubleshooting threads on derailleur adjustment. Modification threads on sequential electronic shifting. Toolbox threads on bottom bracket "standards". Component Wishlist threads titled "ISO: Dura Ace 7400 gruppo". We're even taking over the "Vintage Pedals" thread...The vegans of transportation are coming.
I love this. Lots of great points here! I think you're right on the money about keeping the old bike, even if I wind up being a new one at some point. I love the idea of having that one as a bike to practice mechanical stuff on, gradually upgrade over time, etc etc. I know next to nothing about bike maintenance and repair, so this feels like a good opportunity to get my hands a little more dirty than just the standard tube replacement. I've been going back and forth between buying a used bike in the like, $500-700 range and really shelling out for something between $1500-$2100. If/when i get a new bike I'll probably lean more towards the "most bike I can afford" approach that you mentioned. Buying something on the lower end, while not inherently a bad buy from the dollars-spent viewpoint, feels like I'm just putting money into something that is only marginally better than what my current bike offers after she's all cleaned up and repaired.TLDR
- FIT — to get fit on your bike make sure your bike fits you, including saddle height!
- Suspension — use your built-in suspension over the big bumps by raising your ass off the saddle.
- Discs — can't beat'm in the wet, mechanical ie cable-actuated preferred over hydraulic dribbles.
- Brick&Mortar — don't buy online (yer in Portland!)
- get the most bike you can afford (within reason and purpose)*
- no to electric shifting, just... no.
Don't forget trueing brake discs.I run hydro brakes and prefer them over cable-actuated because they feel stronger, but they are a PITA to work on... lots of tools required to work on them and some run on mineral oil vs regular dot brake fluid, so if you run both type you need separate kits to bleed them yourself. But a good brake bled right can work for many years.