effectslayouts has a tails buffer I found that I will try. The idea is to switch to buffered bypass and use the buffer to filter popping which then send the signal to the effect. You switch between your signal going to the effect or going to the output jack. By having both the effect output and Pin 1 of a DPDT wire to the output jack, you can achieve this. When the effect is turned off the tails will continue as the input to the effect has been bypassed and not the entire circuit. Essentially, the switch will tell your input to either go straight to the output jack or go to the effect, leaving the effect out free of the switching.
I hope that makes sense....it does to me at least.