For starters, can you clean your board really well with some isopropyl alcohol so we can get a good look at the solder joints. Also if you could provide a snap shot of the underside of the board as well. Another question I have is did you make sure your input and output jacks are not touching the black covers on the back of your pots. Not sure if they are metal or not and I can’t judge how close they are to the jack tips when they’re plugged in from the pic.
Where did you get your tl072’s? They look kind of suspect to me. The molding of the package doesn’t look right to me.