I'd use Benny's suggestion, but another way might be to increase the resistance in the second op-amp's feedback loop; stock is 220k so maybe work your way up slowly to where you like it. Start with 240k, 270k, 300k, 330k...
And/Or increase the gain pot from 100k to 250k; or again, add a series resistor to the gain pot and try increasing values until you've got sufficient gain. Of course, adjusting Gain's not gonna achieve the same result as monkeying with the Volume...