Vote for optical illusion.
Switch looks soldered to me, though I can see how it wouldn't if I were on my phone instead of computer.
Looks like the toggle-switches both have blobs that may be cold joints. I'd use a solder-sucker to get rid of the excess and reheat the board's pad and pot-leg and reflow.
Get out the DMM and test for continuity between signal and ground, may be there's a short somewhere....
Pic of the other side of the board SVP. "Rock it before you box it".